CAN ONE LIVE WITHOUT ANY RELIGION ? IF NOT WHY NOT ?
(Discussion in English and Malayalam. Pls read the later comments by
'Athira Snair'. Amazing clarity of thoughts. This is the kind of
resonance I have been searching for. Pls read it to know why)
ഒരു മതത്തിലും ചേരാതെ ജീവിക്കാന് പറ്റുമോ ? ഇല്ലെങ്കില് എന്ത് കൊണ്ട് ?
(ഇത് Free Thinkers ഗ്രൂപ്പില് നടന്ന ചര്ച്ചയുടെ ഭാഗം ആണ്. താഴെ ഇംഗ്ലീഷ് ഇല് 'Athira Snair' എഴുതിയ കമന്റ്സ് നോക്കുക. ഇതാണ് ഞാന് കേള്ക്കാന് ആഗ്രഹിച്ചത് സന്തോഷമായി )
Like · · Share · 3 hours ago near Mumbai
Anish Karim and 6 others like this.
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan തീർച്ചയായിട്ടും
3 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Kattapana Kuttan ഇന്ത്യ ആയതുകൊണ്ട്
3 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Mohammed Jamal ജീവിക്കാന് പറ്റും.. പക്ഷെ മരിക്കാന് ഇത്തിരി പ്രയാസപ്പെടും
3 hours ago · Unlike · 4
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan Kattapana Kuttan അതെന്താ ഇന്ത്യയിൽ മാത്രമേ നിരീശ്വര വാദികൾ ഉള്ളോ?
3 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Kattapana Kuttan അല്ല ഇന്ത്യ നിറയെ ഈശ്വരന്മാര് ആയതുകൊണ്ട്
3 hours ago · Unlike · 2
Lalu Natarajan Mohammed Jamal മരിക്കാന് എന്താ പ്രശ്നം ?
3 hours ago · Like · 1
Mohammed Jamal മരണ ശേഷമാണ് വിശ്വായിയുടെ കര്മഫലം ആരംഭിക്കുന്നത്..
3 hours ago · Like
Anish Karim അതെന്താ മതമില്ലെങ്കില് മരണമില്ലേ ?
3 hours ago · Unlike · 3
Sathish Kumar marikaan vendi jeevikuna kayuthakal...........
3 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Kattapana Kuttan മോഹമദ് : ഈ കര്മ കാരണ ഫലം ആരനുഭാവിക്കും ?
3 hours ago · Like
Praveen V Chengara ഒരു ദുശീലങ്ങളും ഇല്ലാതെ ജീവിച്ചാ എന്ത് രസം ? അതൊക്കെ പോലെ തന്നെ..
3 hours ago · Unlike · 3
Shajeer Majeed Mohammed Jamal ജീവിക്കാന് പറ്റും.. പക്ഷെ മരിക്കാന് ഇത്തിരി പ്രയാസപ്പെടും///
പ്രയാസം മരിക്കാന് ആണോ.. മരിക്കുമ്പോള് ആണോ.. മരിക്കുമ്പോള് ആണെങ്കില് അത് എല്ലാവര്ക്കും ഉണ്ടാകും..
3 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan കൃത്യമായി പറഞ്ഞാൽ :- ഹിന്ദുക്കൾക്ക്
33 കോടിയും, ക്രിസ്ത്യാനികൾക്കും, ജൂതന്മാർക്കും, മുസ്ലീങ്ങൾക്കും ഓരോന്നു
വീതവും ഈശ്വരന്മാർ ഉണ്ട് ...
3 hours ago · Like
Lalu
Natarajan Mohammed Jamal മരണ ശേഷമാണ് വിശ്വായിയുടെ കര്മഫലം
ആരംഭിക്കുന്നത്..: )0 ഇത് ആരോ പറഞ്ഞു കേട്ടതല്ലേ ? നിങ്ങള്ക്ക് ബോദ്ധ്യം
ഉള്ള കാര്യം ആണോ ? അല്ലല്ലോ ? ബോധ്യം ഉള്ള കാര്യങ്ങള് പറയു.
3 hours ago · Edited · Like · 3
Gireesh Bhasker ഈ ചോദ്യം ചോദിക്കാനുള്ള തിരിച്ചറിവുണ്ടാകുമ്പോഴേക്കും നാം മതത്തിന് അടിമയായിരിക്കും.
3 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Kattapana Kuttan ബിമല് : ജീവനുള്ള ദൈവങ്ങള്ക്ക് എന്താ എണ്ണം ഇല്ലേ
3 hours ago · Unlike · 2
Lalu Natarajan Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan: ഹിന്ദുക്കള്ക്ക് 33
കോടി ദൈവങ്ങള്. മറ്റു മതങ്ങള് 300. അപ്പോള് ആകെ ദൈവങ്ങള് 33 കോടി 300.
കണക്കു ശരിയല്ലേ ?
3 hours ago · Edited · Like
Praveen V Chengara അതിനു എണ്ണം ചോദിച്ചാണോ ഈ പോസ്റ്റ് ?
3 hours ago · Like
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan Kattapana Kuttan അവരുടെ എണ്ണം എങ്ങനെ എടുക്കും?
3 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Kattapana Kuttan നാഷണല് ഹൈവേ വഴി ഒന്ന് പോയി നോക്കൂ ബിമല്
....കണ്ണാടി പെട്ടിക്കകത്തും , ഫ്ലെക്സ് ബോര്ഡിലും, നോട്ടീസിലും ഒക്കെ
കാണാം , പിന്നെ പത്രത്തിന്റെ പരസ്യകൊലവും മറക്കാതെ നോക്കൂ ..... ബാക്കി
എണ്ണം അടുത്ത സ്റെപ്പില്...
3 hours ago · Unlike · 3
Lalu Natarajan ഏതെങ്കിലും മതത്തില് ചേരാതെ ജീവിക്കാന് പറ്റില്ല സാധാരണ
മനുഷ്യര്ക്ക്. കാരണം അവര്ക്ക് ലോക ബന്ധങ്ങള് ഉണ്ട്. അവരുടെ കൂടെ
പോകേണ്ടി വരും. വേറെ വഴി ഇല്ല.
3 hours ago · Like
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan ബുദ്ധമതക്കാരാണ് ഭേദം. അവർക്ക് ഈശ്വരൻ ഇല്ല!
3 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Anish Karim അങ്ങനെ അല്ലാതെയും ജീവിക്കാം. പിന്നെ സഹജീവികളുടെ ചില നിര്ബന്ധങ്ങള്ക്ക് വഴങ്ങേണ്ടി വരുമെന്ന് മാത്രം.
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Lalu Natarajan ദൈവ വിശ്വാസികള് ദൈവം ഇല്ലെന്നു പറയുന്ന ബുദ്ധമതക്കാരെ തല്ലി കൊല്ലുമോ ?
2 hours ago · Like · 2
Anish Karim ബുദ്ധമതക്കാരെ തല്ലി കൊല്ലുമോ ?
അങ്ങനെ ഒരു ചരിത്രം കേട്ടിട്ടുണ്ട്.
2 hours ago · Edited · Unlike · 1
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan പക്ഷെ ഇപ്പോൾ ബുദ്ധമതക്കാർ വേറെ ഒരബദ്ധം
കാണിക്കുന്നുണ്ട്. അവർ ശ്രീ ബുദ്ധനെ ദൈവമായിട്ടു ആരാധിക്കുന്നു. ഓരോരോ
വിരോധാഭാസമേ!
2 hours ago · Unlike · 2
Bimal Chellisseril
Sadasivan മനുഷ്യൻ എളുപ്പത്തില് വിശ്വസിക്കുന്ന ഒരു ജീവിയാണ്.
എന്തെങ്കിലുമൊന്നിൽ വിശ്വസിച്ചേ പറ്റൂ. നല്ല കാരണങ്ങൾ ഉള്ള വിശ്വാസം
കിട്ടിയില്ലെങ്കിൽ അവൻ ചീത്ത കാര്യത്തിൽ വിശ്വസിക്കും. - ബർട്രെൻഡ് റസ്സെൽ
2 hours ago · Edited · Unlike · 2
Hakeem Ar Hakeem Ar hi
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Athira Snair you alone are enough to face the sunrise, you don't
need somebody to interpret for you what a beautiful sunrise it is... And
this is my attitude: you are here, every individual is here, the whole
existence is available. All that you need is just to be silent and
listen to existence. There is no need of any religion, there is no need
of any God, there is no need of any priesthood, there is no need of any
organization. I trust in the individual categorically. Nobody up to now
has trusted in the individual in such a way.
2 hours ago · Unlike · 2
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan Athira Snair how long have u been like this?
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Athira Snair for last five years my god is existence....
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Athira Snair i won't go to temple,church or mosques just i will sit
under a tress or go to some natural places like mountains and i will
spend there i can feel the energy and i am in peace this religion is
stupidity for me
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan Athira Snair can u explain the term "energy" precisely?
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Arun Kumar തീര്ച്ചയായും പറ്റും
2 hours ago · Unlike · 2
Athira Snair The energy of the cosmos is surrounding you. All that
is needed is a certain emptiness in you. the energy can neither be
created not be destroyed but we can transform from one form to other as
we studied here also transformation happens like lust to love anger to
joy sadness to blissfulness Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan Athira Snair are u saying that our
emotions like anger, love and lust are manifestations of energy? anyway,
interesting concept!
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Athira
Snair Because we are part of one existence, whomsoever you are hurting,
you are hurting yourself in the long run. Today you may not realize it,
but one day when you become more aware; then you will say, 'My God! This
wound was inflicted by me -- upon myself.' You had hurt somebody else
thinking that people are different. Nobody is different. This whole
existence is one, cosmic unity. Out of this understanding comes
non-violence
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Bimal Chellisseril
Sadasivan Athira Snair we can't live a self-less life forever. sooner
or later our animal instincts must takeover...
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Anish Karim Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan are you trying to say to
overcome our animal instinct we need religion ? or it just needs good
manners and a brain ?
2 hours ago · Edited · Unlike · 2
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan Anish Karim no. i don't subscribe to any
religion whatsoever. but, Athira Snair's concept is different. that's y i
asked...
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Athira Snair sorry
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan i can't make you understand..first you
don’t fill it by beliefs, don’t fill it again by another kind of god,
another philosophy, some existentialism. Don’t fill it. Leave it clean
and fresh, and go deeper You will find it ask to yourself
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan Athira Snair you are starting to sound like an eastern mystic...
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Athira Snair what you want to know Bimal Chellisseril
Sadasivan....no problem you ask about religion also but for me all
religion is stupidity
2 hours ago · Unlike · 1
Lalu
Natarajan Athira Snair: Applause ! Standing ovation. Can you believe you
are the only sensible voice in this whole group ? I am honoured and my
mission with this group is over. I was waiting for resonance,
synchronicity. I hear it in you. Thanks
about an hour ago · Like · 1
Lalu Natarajan Athira Snair : I have a childhood friend named Annamma who works at your college.
about an hour ago · Like · 1
Athira Snair Lalu Natarajan i just said what i feel in my consciousness...thank you
about an hour ago · Unlike · 1
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan Athira Snair yes, i totally agree.
religion arises out of stupidity! but i want to know something. if u
can't make me understand ur philosophy, then how gud is such a thing?
about an hour ago · Edited · Unlike · 1
Athira Snair Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan you ask me what you want to know..?? simple how can i say
about an hour ago · Unlike · 2
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan Athira Snair ok, i get it. let me
rephrase the question.how do u explain ur philosophy? it's a YOU...
about an hour ago · Edited · Unlike · 1
Lalu Natarajan Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan: let me answer that question
about an hour ago · Like · 1
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan Lalu Natarajan go on...
about an hour ago · Like
Lalu Natarajan What Athira Snair says is the simple truth. The
existence is around you. But most donot see it. What they see is their
own mind. Limited, biased, body centric with likes and dislikes. Get
over your own mind. Then your mind becomes no more. Your mind gets lost.
What remains is the existence in its full glory. Live that existence
all by yourself. Be your own master.
59 minutes ago · Like · 1
Zuhair Thangal It is impossible to live as anti islamist among my community. So iam hypocitic..!
59 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Athira Snair more over i am not sharing my philosophy just i am
sharing my own experience..i am not sharing prophet or krishna or christ
or buddha philosophy..“Listen to your being. It is continuously giving
you hints; it is a still, small voice. It does not shout at you, that is
true and that is your consciousness and that is your reality
59 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Athira Snair Zuhair Thangal can i ask one question to you please don't feel bad try to get me an answer
58 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan Athira Snair i beg to disagree...
57 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Kattapana Kuttan athira you sounds weird ...... can you explain that sentence " listen to your being " and follow ....
54 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Lalu Natarajan Zuhair Thangal : Your mind is trapped in some belief
or faith indoctrinated by your religion. You are thinking what is
taught to you. Not your natural free thinking. Someone else's thoughts
have invaded you. Free yourself
54 minutes ago · Like · 2
Athira Snair well said Lalu Natarajan
54 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan Kattapana Kuttan i second that
53 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Zuhair Thangal Sathan trapped me or kuttichathan...!
52 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Athira Snair Kattapana Kuttan there many things which cannot be
explained in simple words can only be experienced its beyond limitation
51 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Kattapana Kuttan a state of insanity
50 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Athira Snair Zuhair Thangal you no need to search sathan outside
its stupidity both sathan and god exist with in you..your good qualities
is god and bad qualities is sathan like wise we can say about heaven
and hell Heaven and hell are not geographical. If you go in search of
them you will never find them anywhere. They are within you, they are
psychological. The mind is heaven, the mind is hell, and the mind has
the capacity to become either. But people go on thinking everything is
somewhere outside. We always go on looking for everything outside
because to be inwards is very difficult. We are outgoing. If somebody
says there is a god, we look at the sky. Somewhere, sitting there, will
be the divine person.
49 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Zuhair Thangal Who said all u think freely! Your thoughts influencedvby sytems and surroundinds..
49 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Lalu Natarajan Zuhair Thangal Osho said. 'Be a Christ. But never
become a Christian ! Be a Mohammed. But never ever become a Mohammedan.
Be another Buddha. No harm. But never become a Buddhist.' Why ? Because
Buddha, Nabi, Jesus etc are original uncorrupted minds. Be like them.No
harm. Free your mind. Live with existence. But the moment one says I
follow someone, your being, originality is gone. Now you are borrowing
someone else's thoughts and think it is yours. It is not. Only your
original thoughts would remain with you whatever you believe. That is
the trap religions do on unsuspecting minds.
47 minutes ago · Like · 1
Zuhair Thangal How can they sit both in the mind..God=Sathan?
45 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Lalu Natarajan Zuhair Thangal It is impossible to live as anti
islamist among my community. So iam hypocitic..!)) : Precisely because
of this reason, all religion and the 'so called' religious people would
be against a free soul like Osho. Because he does not adjust to
someone's thoughts. Because he can think himself. Religions want dumb
fearful believers. Not fearless bright free thinkers.
19 minutes ago · Edited · Like · 1
Athira Snair your own experience is your spirituality as Lalu
Natarajan said about osho...what you people are studying is some people
experiences which happens centuries before now world is changed a lot
and god has give you the energy to find out your consciousness
44 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Kattapana Kuttan any chemical substance can change or could
influence " your being / existence of full glory, such like .... '
things '....
43 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Athira Snair
Zuhair Thangal you people believes that god creates all then you try to
find out who must created this sathan also
42 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Zuhair Thangal Did you read my comments? Why blame u people..? I
dont want represent any absurd ideologies. No sathan.. No god.. That was
what i hinted
40 minutes ago · Unlike · 1
Athira Snair yes Zuhair Thangal if i amke you feel bad i am so sorry
33 minutes ago · Unlike · 3
Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan Athira Snair “Listen to your being. It
is continuously giving you hints; it is a still, small voice. It does
not shout at you, that is true and that is your consciousness and that
is your reality" - EXPAIN THIS
28 minutes ago · Like
Lalu Natarajan Bimal Chellisseril Sadasivan: Any amount of explanation will not satify.
16 minutes ago · Like
Lalu Natarajan You have to experience yourself. Those who
experienced can only guide the rest. To follow or not is their problem.
16 minutes ago · Like
Muralik Thrichur ഇല്ലെന്നാരു പറഞ്ഞു
12 minutes ago · Like
Anish Karim
Anish Karim's photo.
11 minutes ago · Like
Zuhair Thangal I am not a believer but i am compelled to live as an
hypocritic.. Our social back ground doesnt support to live freely..
Financial back ground is a main thing